I recently completed a certain long anticipated manuscript, and I’m currently in the process of rewriting and revising it. Editing this thing has me thinking about a certain line from Macbeth, which I’ll paraphrase as: I have walked so deep into blood that, should I go no farther, returning will be as tedious as continuing onward.
That’s morbid, I know. What do you expect? It’s Shakespeare! But simply replace the word blood with red ink, and I think you’ll understand how the editing is going for me.
Anyway, I’ve waded so far into that “red ink” that I haven’t had much time for research; so for today’s episode of Molecular Monday I thought we’d take a look back at one of my older posts. A very old post, from all the way back in 2011, long before I really knew what I was talking about with regard to organic chemistry.
And yet despite my ignorance and inexperience, I think I still got the general idea right with this one. Also, this post includes one of my very first attempts at science illustration, so I hope you’ll enjoy that!
CARBON vs. SILICON
It’s often suggested that the aliens from the Aliens movies, sometimes referred to as xenomorphs, are silicon based rather than carbon based like us. There are a lot of silicon based aliens in science fiction, but no one knows if such a thing is really possible.
Carbon and silicon have one thing in common: they both have four bonding sites, meaning they can bond with up to four other atoms when making a molecule. Other than that, they’re completely different. Silicon is a metalloid; carbon is a nonmetal. Carbon is much lighter and more flexible, and it’s ten times more abundant in the universe.
If the idea of silicon based life is simply to replace carbon atoms with silicon, it wouldn’t work. Take breathing for example. We breath oxygen in, and exhale carbon dioxide. When a silicon based alien breaths in oxygen, it will have a hard time exhaling silicon dioxide; silicon dioxide is better known as quartz crystal.
I don’t remember any xenomorphs hacking up quartz crystals in the movies, but maybe they use silicon for something else. Carbon has to be part of their biochemistry anyway, or they wouldn’t be able to grow inside human hosts.
Humans are not only carbon based. We also depend on oxygen, nitrogen, hydrogen, phosphorus, and sulfur. Not only that, but we need traces of iron, sodium, potassium, etc as well. So maybe the xenomorphs can be carbon based and silicon based at the same time.
4 thoughts on “Molecular Monday: Carbon vs. Silicon”
Fascinating! I love reading your posts!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you! I’m glad you like them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow. This is a great post. I didn’t see it the first time around, so thsks for reposting it. It’s a handy tool, reposting is. Good luck with the editing and I hope wherever the manuscript takes you is amazing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks! The editing, or rather the complete rewriting, is turning out to be not as bad as I thought it would be.