I Like Big Moons and I Cannot Lie

Why is Earth so special? Why did life develop and thrive here and (as far as we know) nowhere else in the Solar System? These are questions scientists and science fiction writers alike must puzzle over. Part of the answer may involve Earth’s ginormous moon.

Please note: for the sake of clarity, I’ll refer to Earth’s moon as Luna in today’s post even though that is not the Moon’s official I.A.U. name.

Although Luna is not the largest moon in the Solar System (that honor goes to Ganymede), the mass ratio between Earth and Luna is way, way out of whack compared to other planet/moon combinations. A moon as large as Luna has no business orbiting a planet as small as Earth.

So what’s the effect of Luna’s relatively large size?

My09 Stability

Scientists have speculated that Luna’s gravity does more than create tides. It may also help stabilize Earth’s orbital axis.

According to at least some computer simulations, Earth could easily tilt sideways by as much as 85 degrees if not for Luna’s constant gravitational tug. This would lead to sudden and dramatic changes to the global climate. Changes that life might not be able to cope with.

If that’s true, then disproportionately large moons like Luna may be necessary for all life-bearing planets. Since Luna-like moons are surely rare, this drastically limits the chances of finding life elsewhere in the universe. Which totally sucks (not a scientific evaluation, just my opinion).

However, there may be other possibilities. For example, some simulations indicate that a moonless Earth could still keep itself balanced thanks to the gravitational influence of Jupiter.

The lesson for science fiction writers is that life-bearing planets probably need something to hold them steady. Whether that something is a Luna-like moon, a Jupiter-like planet, or some other large nearby object is up to the writer’s imagination. At least until science provides us with more conclusive data.


Earth’s Stabilizing Moon May Be Unique Within Universe from Space.com.

The Odds for Life on a Moonless Earth from Astrobiology Magazine.

* * *

Today’s post is part of Moon month for the 2015 Mission to the Solar System. Click here for more about this series.

5 thoughts on “I Like Big Moons and I Cannot Lie

  1. I’ve wondered about the Moon stability thing for a while. It seems to be borne out if we look at Venus, which is dramatically tilted with a very slow retrograde rotation. But Mars seems a lot more like us in this regard, and all it’s got are a couple of tiny asteroids for moons. (Although maybe Jupiter is what rescued it.) The question is, what keeps Jupiter’s rotation stable?

    But I tend to suspect that most life will be on moons in orbit around gas giants (mostly in close orbit around red dwarfs). In that case, the gas giant will probably provide some stability, with the moon typically tidally locked to it, but with its orbit varying its sun exposure in a day/night cycle.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m hoping to revisit this whole stability issue when we get to Uranus month. I agree with you about life on moons. I recently read something about astronomers trying to identify exomoons orbiting exoplanets, so maybe we’ll get to learn more about that in the coming years.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.